Skip to content

NOT The Finals After All!

June 5, 2010

I would be pissed too!

Previously, I had reported that the “Powers that ‘Bee'” had cut round 6 short and all the people left would get a free pass to the finals.  That’s not actually the case:

O’Neal walked onstage Friday at the Scripps National Spelling Bee and challenged last year’s winner to a spell-off, but he didn’t generate anywhere near the passion created by a decision to suspend the semifinals so there would be enough spellers left for ABC’s prime-time broadcast Friday night.

The result was 10 spellers advancing to the championship broadcast, including six who didn’t have to spell a word in the interrupted round. Essentially, the alphabetical order of the U.S. states determined which spellers got to move on the marquee event.

“I would rather have five finalists, than five who didn’t deserve it,” said 13-year-old Elizabeth Platz of Shelbina, Mo., one of the four spellers who spelled a word correctly before the round was stopped. “I think it was unfair.”

Elizabeth’s remarks were greeted with applause from parents in the hotel ballroom where the bee is held.

It’s one of the pitfalls of the growing popularity of the bee, which has to yield to the constraints of its television partners. There were 19 spellers left at the start of the round, which was too many for prime-time. But when the round turned out to be brutal — nine of the first 13 misspelled — ABC was on the verge of having too few.

“I don’t feel bad at all for giving these children the opportunity,” bee director Paige Kimble said. “Do I wish we could give it to 19? Yes, certainly, but that’s not practical in a two-hour broadcast window. We know it’s unpopular and we don’t like to do it, but sometimes you can get into a position where that’s exactly what you have to do.”

Kimble stressed that the move was within the rules and that the round would pick up where it left off. Only the spellers remaining at the end of the round would officially be declared finalists.

So six spellers get to rest up, review one more time and see prime time tv while four had to earn the right earlier.
Is it fairer than simply bumping them up? Absolutely! Is it fair in general? Probably not.

Raf N. at A List of Things Thrown 5 Minutes Ago sums it up well:

Look, life’s not fair. Eventually, you find that out – I have, over and over, in good times and in bad. It’s a hell of a lesson to learn when you’re 13 years old, on a stage like this. While I think it’s fair that the Bee is resuming Round 6 from the cut-off point, I can’t help thinking that a fairer solution would’ve been playing out the string in the afternoon, and if you had wound up with four finalists, well, then, so be it.

Anyways, I DO feel good about the prospects of the homeschoolers after this. I just hope that we don’t see a repeat of this next year.


From → Uncategorized

Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: